1 / 13

Hook Score9/10

9/10

The combination of a 'Top 8' listicle and a visually creepy image creates an immediate curiosity gap that is hard to ignore.

Slide Text

Top 8 most haunted places in Illinois

Visual

A dark, moody, slightly desaturated photo of an old house with a figure visible in the window.

All Slides

Carousel report cardParanormal travel / Local horror history13 slides

@1700bones carousel breakdown

Happy Nightmare

Illinois is home to some of the most haunted places in the Midwest, where history and ghost stories intertwine. From the eerie halls of the Old Joliet Prison to the ghostly hitchhiker of Resurrection Mary, each site carries chilling tales of tragedy and mystery #horrortok #halloween #scary #illinois #haunted

Effectiveness score

8/10

Strong

Views

478.5K

Likes

26.6K

Saves

6.3K

Engagement

7.5%

Hook

Top 8 most haunted places in Illinois

Goal

grow-following

Offer

entertainment

CTA

none

View source

Caption

Strategic Summary

This carousel wins by hyper-localizing a broad niche (horror) to a specific geography (Illinois), triggering both tourism curiosity and local pride. The high bookmark rate (2.2x norm) indicates users are saving this as a travel bucket list, while the high comment rate (1.8x norm) is driven by locals validating or debunking the locations based on personal proximity. The inconsistent numbering (skipping #7, #5, #3, #1 labels) accidentally fuels engagement as users notice the gaps.

The Winning Formula

Hyper-localized fear list + archival visual proof + invitation for local testimony.

What's working

•Slide 1 promise ('Top 8') sets a clear completion goal for the swiper.
•Slide 2 uses a red circle on a grainy photo — a classic visual trope that forces the eye to search for the 'ghost', increasing dwell time.
•Slide 6 uses a raw newspaper clipping instead of a polished graphic, adding authentic historical weight to the horror claim.
•Slide 8 saves the most recognizable location (Joliet Prison) for last, rewarding completion with the highest-status item.
•Geographic specificity filters the audience to people who live near or plan to visit these spots, skyrocketing relevance.

What's not working

•Numbering is inconsistent (Slides 4, 6, 8 lack numbers; Slide 3 jumps to #6), which may confuse users tracking the count.
•Slide 6 lacks a location name on the image itself, relying on caption knowledge, causing confusion in comments ('What's the story behind Resurrection Cemetery?').
•Slide 3 text ('aka The Old Slave House') overlaps slightly with the roofline, reducing readability on smaller screens.

Viral lesson

Localizing a universal interest (horror) creates a stronger community feedback loop than generic content because it invites personal testimony ('I live near this') rather than passive consumption.

Can a small creator replicate this? Highly replicable for any creator with local knowledge; requires access to public domain archival photos or original photography of specific local landmarks.

Structural Formula (steal-the-format)

Structure pattern

8-slide list, numbered countdown (with intentional or accidental gaps), mix of exterior and interior shots, final slide is the most recognizable landmark.

Copy formula

Numbered header + Location Name + (Optional) Alias/Context.

What to swap (concrete remixes)

•Swap Illinois→Your State for local tourism boards.
•Swap Haunted Places→Best Hidden Gems for food/travel creators.
•Swap Horror→True Crime for narrative storytellers.

What NOT to copy

Do not copy the inconsistent numbering unless you want to invite confusion; ensure every slide has a clear location label unlike Slide 6.

Aesthetics

Archival horror collage mixing grainy B&W, sepia, and modern decay photography.

design:mid tiertypography:White sans serif text in rounded bubbles, high contrast.visual consistency:75/100attention grab:85/100

Color palette

sepiadark greypeeling whitebrick red

What it conveys: The mix of vintage clippings and decayed interiors creates a sense of authentic, historical unease rather than cheap jump scares.

Slide-by-slide forensics

hookwide shotforebodingworks:yesgrab:90/100aesthetic:85/100

Top 8 most haunted places in Illinois

Visual description

A low-angle shot of a large, two-story house with a wraparound porch and white columns. The sky is dark and stormy, giving a menacing vibe. The image has a grainy, filtered look.

Scene setting

exterior of creepy house at dusk

Visible objects

houseporchcolumnsstairs

vs prior slide

style:yescopy:yesenergy:rising

Style: Sets the dark, grainy aesthetic for the rest of the carousel.

Story: Establishes the premise and geographic scope.

Predicted audience reaction

Illinois locals stop scrolling immediately due to geographic relevance.

Verdict: Strong hook combining a numbered list promise with a specific location.

step in listmedium shotuneaseworks:yesgrab:85/100aesthetic:70/100

#8 - Bachelor's Grove Cemetery

Visual description

A grainy black and white photograph of a wooded area. A red circle is drawn around a faint, seated figure near a tree, implying a ghost.

Scene setting

cemetery woods

Visible people

faint figure ( ghost )

Visible objects

treetombstone

vs prior slide

style:yescopy:yesenergy:flat

Style: Continues the grainy, archival photo aesthetic.

Story: Begins the countdown at #8.

Predicted audience reaction

Skepticism or recognition from locals who know this famous spot.

Comments reacting to this slide

"Bachelors grove the lamest location 😭"

Verdict: The red circle forces the user to examine the image closely, increasing dwell time.

step in listwide shothistoricworks:yesgrab:70/100aesthetic:75/100

#6 - The Crenshaw House aka The Old Slave House

Visual description

A colorized vintage photo of a red two-story house with white trim and a white fence. A red pickup truck is parked in front. The sky is blue but textured.

Scene setting

historic house exterior

Visible objects

housepickup truckfence

vs prior slide

style:partialcopy:yesenergy:flat

Style: Shifts from B&W grain to colorized vintage, but maintains retro feel.

Story: Jumps from #8 to #6, skipping #7.

Predicted audience reaction

Locals recognize the landmark and comment on proximity.

Comments reacting to this slide

"i live 5 minutes away from the crenshaw house"

Verdict: Triggers local pride and proximity comments which boost algorithmic engagement.

step in listwide shotdecayworks:yesgrab:85/100aesthetic:80/100

McPike Mansion

Visual description

Interior shot of a dilapidated room. Blue peeling paint on walls, exposed brick, debris on the floor, and an arched window. Looks abandoned and decayed.

Scene setting

abandoned mansion interior

Visible objects

windowdebrischairdoorframe

vs prior slide

style:yescopy:partialenergy:rising

Style: Returns to a darker, more textured aesthetic similar to Slide 1.

Story: No number listed, breaks the countdown pattern.

Predicted audience reaction

Visuals of decay are highly shareable for horror fans.

Comments reacting to this slide

"I live 6 mins from McPike mansion"

Verdict: Strong visual evidence of 'haunting' through decay drives saves.

step in listwide shoteerieworks:partialgrab:65/100aesthetic:70/100

#4 - Ashmore Estates

Visual description

Sepia-toned photograph of a large brick institutional building. Looks like an old asylum or estate. Overgrown grass in foreground.

Scene setting

historic institution exterior

Visible objects

buildingwindowsgrass

vs prior slide

style:yescopy:yesenergy:flat

Style: Consistent vintage/sepia tone.

Story: Resumes numbering at #4.

Predicted audience reaction

Recognition from those familiar with Illinois asylums.

Verdict: Less engaging than the interior decay shot; no specific comments reference it directly.

prooftext cardtragicworks:partialgrab:75/100aesthetic:60/100

GIRL IS KILLED, 5 HURT AS AUTO FALLS IN DITCH One girl was killed instantly and five other members of an automobile party were injured, one probably fatally, last night when the automobile in which they were riding went off the road into a ditch and overturned at Harlem avenue and 66th street, near Argo. The dead girl is Anna Norkus, 12 years old, 5421 South Neva avenue. She was crushed under the car. The injured are William Wasnor, 32 years old, 3148 Auburn avenue; Loretta Gwozdz, 14 years old, 5312 South Nottingham avenue; Adam Lepinski, 58 years old; August Norkus, 42 years old, 5421 South Neva avenue, and Sophie Norkus, 16 years old, 5421 South Neva

Visual description

A black and white newspaper clipping with a bold headline about a fatal car accident. Text is dense and legible.

Scene setting

newspaper archive

Visible objects

newspaper clipping

vs prior slide

style:partialcopy:noenergy:rising

Style: Shifts from photo to text document, breaking visual flow but adding authenticity.

Story: Provides backstory (Resurrection Mary) without naming the location on slide.

Predicted audience reaction

Confusion about location but intrigue about the story.

Comments reacting to this slide

"What's the story behind Resurrection Cemetery? I've been there many times but it's very normal"

Verdict: Drives comments asking for clarification, but lacks the location name on-slide for context.

step in listwide shoturbanworks:yesgrab:80/100aesthetic:75/100

#2 - Congress Plaza Hotel

Visual description

Daylight photo of a large beige hotel building with a red neon sign on top reading 'CONGRESS HOTEL'. City street scene with buses and traffic lights.

Scene setting

city street

Visible objects

hotelbusstreet lightsneon sign

vs prior slide

style:nocopy:yesenergy:rising

Style: Shifts to modern color photography, breaking the vintage aesthetic.

Story: Moves to #2, building anticipation for #1.

Predicted audience reaction

High recognition value for Chicago locals.

Comments reacting to this slide

"I stayed at the congress once, nothing really happened. It did feel really Erie though"
"I stayed at congress, nothing happens. just weird vibes on the fourth floor where room 441 doesn't exist anymore"

Verdict: Generates significant personal testimony comments about staying there.

revealperspective shotconfinementworks:yesgrab:95/100aesthetic:90/100

Old Joliet Prison

Visual description

Interior hallway of a prison. Cell bars on the right, peeling paint on the ceiling and walls, metal grate flooring on the left. Dark and atmospheric.

Scene setting

prison corridor

Visible objects

cell barsceiling debrisfloor grate

Other text elements

•340

vs prior slide

style:yescopy:partialenergy:rising

Style: Returns to dark, decayed aesthetic matching Slide 1 and 4.

Story: The implied #1 spot, ending the list.

Predicted audience reaction

High recognition, pop culture references (Silent Hill, Prison Break).

Comments reacting to this slide

"Old Joliet prison reminds me of silent hill"
"Real ones know what show was filmed at Joliet prison top 5 series oat"
"Just went to Joliet haunted prison"

Verdict: Strongest visual in the deck; anchors the entire carousel's credibility.

Commerce intent

intent:15/100framework:nonetraveltourism

Buy-intent phrases (from comments)

•10 out of 10 recommend

Objections (from comments)

•Bachelors grove the lamest location
•nothing really happened

Comment ethnography

tagging:community debateaudience-match:90/100viral signal:debate stack

Locals are challenging the creator's rankings or validating them with personal proximity claims ('I live 5 minutes away').

Comments that characterize the audience

"I live 5 minutes away from the crenshaw house"
"Old Joliet prison reminds me of silent hill"
"I stayed at the congress once, nothing really happened"

Pain points revealed

•Want to know the specific lore/story behind the image
•Want to verify if locations are actually haunted before visiting

Aspirations revealed

•Want to visit these locations for thrill-seeking
•Want to be seen as a local expert on haunted spots

Create content like this for your brand

Add a card, onboard your brand, and generate the first creative workflow for free.